"Fully mature and not nearly as intense as more recent vintages since 2005, this wine has a plum/garnet color, with some noticeable lightening at the edge. Roasted herbs intermixed with damp earth, charcoal, barbecue smoke, and red and black currants give it a very appealing attack and mid-palate, but it narrows out quickly in the abrupt finish. It is fully mature and best drunk up."
Robert Parker 86 Punkte
"This is a pleasant, lighter-styled, deep ruby/plum-colored wine with medium body, some weediness in the aromas and flavors, good ripeness in the attack, but a quick, relatively abrupt finish. Anticipated maturity: now-2010."
Robert Parker 86 Punkte
"The 2000 appears to have put on more weight, and is better than I indicated in issue #139. While not one of the great Phelan Segurs, it should merit a score of (86-87)."
Robert Parker 86-87 Punkte
Quelle: www.robertparker.com